| Present Day Name | Former Name(s) |
|---|
| Eagle Island | Green Island |
| Tweed Island |
|
| Guernsey Island | Weebol (Weeball) |
| Bottle Cove |
|
| Pearl Island | Big Island |
| Lark Harbour |
|
| Woods Islands | Woods Island Harbour and Innismara* |
| Cox's Cove |
|
| North Arm |
|
| Cook's Brook | Brook's Cove, Shoal Point, Chile's Point, Ballantine Cove, Pleasant Cove, Allen's Cove, and Petrie Valley |
| Middle Arm |
|
| Goose Arm |
|
| Wild Cove |
|
| Blow Me Down | Madore Cove and Gallant Cove* |
| York Harbour | Broom's Bottom and York Harbour* |
| Humber Arm |
|
| Frenchman's Cove | Frenchman's Cove and Long Cove* |
| McIver's |
|
| Johns Beach |
|
| Benoit's Cove | Baken Cove, Batteau Cove, Hawke's Cove, and Clarkes Brook |
| Halfway Point |
|
| Serpentine River |
|
| Mount Moriah |
|
| Gillams |
|
| Meadows | Barber's Cove, Brake's Point, Meadow's Point |
| Summerside | McCarthyville, Christopher's Cove, Quigley's Cove, Petipas Cove |
| Petries | Petries Point |
| Curling | Birchy Cove, Sprucey Point, Deep Cove |
| Irishtown |
|
| Hughes Brook |
|
| Humbermouth | Riverhead |
| Massey Drive |
|
| Corner Brook |
|
| * was once more than one community |